10 Worst Homeowners Insurance Companies in Florida 2022

10 Worst Homeowners Insurance Companies in Florida 2024

Posted by

Worst insurance companies for paying claims

What is Homeowners insurance?

Homeowners insurance is a type of insurance that protects the property and possessions of an individual or a family against damage or loss. It covers the cost of repairing or replacing items covered by the policy.

The most common types of coverage are liability, property damage, personal liability, theft and medical payments.

Worst insurance companies in Florida: Background & History of the Insurance Industry in Florida

Insurance companies in Florida have been criticized for their lack of customer service and high rates.

The insurance industry in Florida has a long history dating back to the 1800s when the first insurance company was established. The industry is one of the most competitive in the state, with over 1,300 insurance companies operating in Florida.

There are many factors that contribute to the success of an insurance company, including a strong claim department and a good customer service team. However, there are also many factors that contribute to an insurance company’s failure, such as not being able to meet claims or having poor customer service.

In 2023, the insurance companies mentioned below are among Florida’s worst-rated insurance companies. The scores are based on the firms’ reviews and after-sales service.

1. Service Plus

In the year 2023, Service Plus was the worst insurance business ever. Customers have warned customers to avoid these organizations since they never make claims that last more than six months.

It is preferable not to purchase insurance from Service Plus and instead save your money for this company.

2. Farmers

Farmers Insurance makes millions of dollars in earnings each year despite continuously low customer satisfaction ratings. Furthermore, the insurance company’s financial growth has proven to be impressive.

Consumer Reports and JD Powers & Associates, on the other hand, rank it as one of the worst auto and house insurance providers in the country. It is one of the worst insurance companies for paying claims in Florida.

To limit payments to users, the corporation employs a variety of tactics. It also rewards employees who meet their low-pay targets with bonuses.Worst insurance companies for paying claims

Adjusters are taught to put profits over policyholder interests and rights, according to sources. As a result, if adjusters are successful in lowering payments by persuading clients to accept lowball offers, they may be eligible for raises, bonuses, and other perks.

3. Conseco

Conseco, an Indiana-based long-term care insurer, was rated one of America’s 10 worst insurance businesses for denial and delay of long-term care claim payments by the American Association for Justice (AAJ). The following is an example of a Conseco customer review:

“Our father was covered by a life insurance policy held by three members of our family.” Due to delaying tactics, payment has already been delayed for two months. At all costs, stay away from these guys. Before charging you a dime, [they] will give you the long-term run-around for as long as they can!”

4. Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual has an NAIC rating of 2.22, suggesting that it has received more customer complaints than the average auto and home insurance provider. Poor service, unexpected rate increases, and sluggish claims processing are among the most common Liberty Mutual customer complaints.

Liberty Mutual began abandoning and rejecting renewal requests from consumers in high-risk locations, such as those prone to hurricanes or floods, according to sources.

5. Anthem

Anthem, formerly WellPoint, is a health and homeowner insurance provider that promises to cover a wide range of insurance categories through its Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans.

Anthem regularly fails to provide coverage despite numerous government reprimands and fines in recent years for canceling coverage or withholding payment on covered claims. It is one of the worst insurance companies for paying claims in Florida.

The corporation, according to reports, has required that doctors submit personal information about customers’ pre-existing ailments in order to withdraw their coverage.

Types of Insurance Claims and How Insurance Claims Work

6. AIG

AIG is the world’s largest insurance company, according to analysts, and CEO Brian Duperreault made more than $19 million in 2019. Furthermore, thanks to its objective of paying out on as few claims as possible, company earnings continue to climb.

AIG is now known as the worst home insurance provider due to billions in corporate malfeasance, including price rises after catastrophic disasters and a $68 million pending payoff to its ex-CEO.

7. Allstate

In terms of the worst firms in 2023, Allstate is among the top ten worst insurance companies in Florida. Allstate has also been condemned for utilizing unclear policy language, which has led to policyholders believing they had complete coverage when claims are denied.

The company’s purpose, according to experts, is to collect money from clients who believe they have complete coverage but have little or no choice when calamity strikes. All of this has resulted in a wave of negative news for Allstate in the insurance business.

8. Torchmark

This freshly rebranded insurance firm, formerly known as Global Life, primarily serves Alabama, Texas, and other southern states. The corporation adopts some fairly harsh practices after 100 years in numerous iterations.

Low-income Americans are targeted, non-English-speaking Americans are covered, and senior citizens are sold bogus Medicare and homeowner insurance. It is one of the worst insurance companies for paying claims in Florida.

9. Progressive

Progressive used to be a customer-focused insurance firm that was courteous and helpful. On the other hand, recent court cases depict a totally different picture. It is one of the worst home insurance companies in Florida.

Progressive has faced a slew of high-stakes bad faith insurance claims from policyholders and claimants in recent years. Some of these insurance claims have been settled, but others are still being worked out.

Progressive is accused of failing to settle claims involving severe injuries to children caused by Progressive policyholders in several of these situations. One similar lawsuit resulted in a $22 million settlement.

Another lawsuit seeks $50 million in damages for Progressive’s bad faith claim handling.


The worst homeowners insurance in Florida in 2023 was covered in this post. As we collected and examined the data ourselves about each detail of the above house insurance companies in 2023, we described each point about the firm that is good or poor based on its reports and client feedback.

READ: Business Property Insurance Guide for Beginners

Filing a Florida Bad Faith Insurance Lawsuit

If you’ve been the victim of a bad faith insurance fraud, you’ll need the assistance of an expert attorney who can help you get the money you deserve.

As a policyholder, you can expect your claims to be paid according to the conditions of your policy. Even if you have a valid claim, insurance companies may use a variety of tactics to avoid paying you. Here are some of the reasons why insurance companies refuse to pay:

Delaying processing – When an insurance company becomes delinquent in their payments, they may drag out the application backlog period to avoid making a payment.

Skewing evidence – Insurers often choose to deny claims, so that they have evidence regarding the case. However, they will not be able to properly argue their stance when selecting evidence arbitrarily.

Using invalid claim reviews – Insurers have the right to reject claims based on the testimony of a doctor, even if it occurs after an emergency. With an emergency situation, you might not be able to get a professional in time or at all.

Failure to conduct thorough research – It is important that every part of the case is reviewed so that an accurate decision can be made. It’s not just the parts that favor one side or the other which need to be considered.

Using deceptive practices – This policy is for personal liability only, but the insurer may offer coverage for injuries caused by collision. It’s important that you find out what coverage you have & understand how much it pays before your policy expires so that you can plan accordingly.

Cancelled policies – In rare cases, an insurance company might cancel your policy for a variety of reasons. In the worst case, if this happens your claim may not be paid.

The Five Factors Florida Uses to Determine Bad Faith

Bad faith insurance cases must be filed “after a third party obtains a judgment,” according to Florida law. To assess if bad faith has occurred, these five characteristics must be evaluated.

  1. How does coverage affect the claim?

  2. Whether or whether the insurance carried out a comprehensive inquiry into the claim.

  3. Whether the insurer dealt with the matter in a timely and non-prejudiceful manner.

  4. Whether the insured was given notice of the insurer’s right to deny coverage, as well as an explanation for why the claim was denied.

  5. Whether or not the insurer attempted to settle the claim notwithstanding the coverage dispute

If your claim is covered by your policy and the liability is evident, but your insurer refuses to pay, you may be entitled to compensation. You may be eligible to sue for both compensatory and punitive damages.

The Rise of Direct Selling and Deregulation of the Insurance Industry

Direct selling is a business model that allows individuals and companies to sell products or services directly to consumers without the use of intermediaries.

The direct selling industry has been around since the early 1900s, but it has seen a significant spike in recent years. In 2017, direct sellers generated $42 billion in sales.

Deregulation of the insurance industry refers to the process of removing government restrictions on the insurance industry.

5 Ways to Avoid Getting Screwed by an Insurer After a Disaster

1. Get a good insurance agent

2. Get a good insurance company

3. Make sure your policy covers what you need it to cover

4. Make sure your policy is up-to-date and not due for renewal soon

5. Don’t wait until disaster strikes to get insurance.

Why We Chose Florida for Our List of Worst Insurance Companies

Florida is one of the most popular states for people to move to. It has a warm climate, beautiful beaches, and is known for its tourism industry.

However, Florida also has some of the worst insurance companies in the United States. We looked at all 50 states and chose Florida as one of our worst insurance companies due to their high rates and lack of customer service.

3 Ways to Find the Best Florida Insurance Company for You

Florida is an ideal destination for a wide range of outdoor activities, and there are plenty of insurance companies that cater to the needs of those who want to stay active.

Florida is a popular destination for many people, with its warm weather and beautiful beaches. However, it can also be a dangerous place with high rates of crime and natural disasters. In order to ensure that you are covered in case anything happens while you are on vacation, it is important to shop around for the best Florida insurance company.

When choosing an insurance company in Florida, there are a few factors that you should consider: what kind of coverage do they offer? Do they have offices all over Florida? Do they offer discounts for those who take extra precautions? Are they easy to reach by phone or online? How long have they been in business?